Penalties and Defenses for 1st Degree Assault in California.
Assault charges in California have varying penalties and possible defenses depending on the case at hand. Here’s what you need to know about 1st degree assault in California.
Generally, most “simple” assault is classified as a misdemeanor in California, which includes first-degree assault. There are predetermined maximum punishments for nearly every type of assault case, and these punishments typically depend on the location and victim of the crime. Defenses for each incident, however, will vary depending on how the accused or the accused’s attorney chooses to handle the case.
What is Assault?
As defined by California law, an assault is an illegal attempt, accompanied by a present ability, to inflict a violent injury on another person. In other words, when an individual attempts to physically harm another individual in person, it is considered assault. Assault only involves the potential to harm someone – the action simply needs to have the strong possibility to inflict an injury to be feasibly considered assault.
An example of assault would be if an individual attempted to punch someone but missed.
Assault often becomes confused with battery because the two are closely associated. The main difference between the two is that assault only involves an attempt to harm another, while battery concerns the actual infliction of harm.
General Penalties for Assault in California
Simple Assault in California is punishable either by a maximum fine of $1000 or by a county jail imprisonment for up to 6 months. An individual found guilty of assault could also be sentenced to a combination of a monetary fine and imprisonment within those limits. This punishment is used in most assault cases and can be considered the “generic” punishment.
Related: Assault vs Aggravated Assault: The Difference
Special Cases with Increased Penalties in California
While most cases will fall under the general penalty stated above, there are variations of this baseline penalty depending on the location and victim of the alleged assault. California Penal Code 240 outlines special instances of assault.
Assaults Against Certain Employees
If an individual assaults anyone with the following occupations who are in the process of conducting their jobs’ duties, and the individual should have a reasonable understanding that the person holds one of the following occupations, they can face steeper fines or imprisonment:
- A peace officer
- Firefighter
- Emergency medical technician
- Mobile intensive care paramedic
- Lifeguard
- Process server
- Traffic officer
- Code enforcement officer
- Animal control officer
- Search and rescue member
- A school employee
- Highway worker
The alleged assaulter would face a maximum fine of $2000, or a county jail imprisonment for up to one year. They could also be sentenced to a combination of a monetary fine and imprisonment within those limits.
Assaults in Specific Areas
If an assault is conducted on school or park grounds, regardless of the victim, the alleged assaulter could face a maximum fine of $2000, or a county jail imprisonment for up to one year as well as a combination of the two.
If an assault is committed on the motor vehicle of a public transportation provider, the alleged assaulter could face a maximum fine of $2000, or a county jail imprisonment for up to one year as well as a combination of the two.
Assault with a Deadly Weapon
If an assault is conducted with a deadly weapon, such as a firearm or knife, the alleged assaulter could face either a misdemeanor conviction with a jail sentence of up to one year or a felony conviction with a jail sentence of up to 4 years. They could also alternatively face a fine of up to $10,000.
Related: Assault vs Sexual Assault in California
Defenses for Assault in California
There are multiple defenses individuals may use to defend themselves against accusations of assault. The four main defenses are:
- The accused acted in self-defense
- The accused did not act willfully
- The accused did not have the ability or physical presence to inflict harm on the alleged victim
- The accused was falsely accused
1. Acting in Self-Defense
There are three elements needed to prove self-defense in an assault case:
- The accused reasonably assumed that they were in immediate danger of being injured
- The accused reasonably assumed that physical force was necessary to defend themselves against this immediate danger
- The accused only used the necessary amount of force to get rid of the danger
An example of self-defense would be if individual A was punched by individual B and then pushed individual B away from themselves to prevent a second punch.
2. Not Acting Willfully or With Intent
If the accused’s attempt to use force against another person was not willful, then they cannot be guilty of assault in California.
For example, if individual A trips and falls, accidentally bumping into individual B on the way down, individual A could not be convicted of assault because they were not willfully inflicting harm onto individual B.
3. No Ability or Physical Presence to Inflict Harm
An accused individual cannot be convicted of assault if they were physically unable to inflict harm on the alleged victim.
For example, one night, individual A and individual B become verbally hostile towards one another, but they are quickly pulled to opposite sides of the street and restrained. Individual A punches the air. Individual A could not be convicted of assault in California because they lack the physical ability to inflict injury onto individual B – they are too far away and are restrained.
4. False Accusations
False accusations of assault are more common than many think. False accusations are not uncommon because, under California Law, the actual physical injury does not need to be inflicted on the alleged victim. If falsely accused, individuals should consult with an experienced attorney to determine how to proceed.
FAQs About 1st Degree Assault in California
What if a minor is the alleged assaulter?
If a minor assaults someone on school property, then they may additionally be required to attend counseling at their parents’ expense. For other situations, it may be helpful to consult with an experienced juvenile attorney to determine the charges the minor may face.
Are the penalties for battery different from the penalties for assault?
Yes. In California, the general penalty for assault is a maximum $1000 fine or up to 6 months in jail, while the general penalty for battery is a maximum $2000 fine or up to 6 months in prison.
If I hit someone and then they try to hit back, can I accuse them of assault?
While they could be accused of assault because they did try to punch back, their actions can easily be considered self-defense, and they would likely not be convicted. The person who started the fight, however, would likely be convicted.
Contact Us
If you or a loved one would like to learn more about 1st Degree Assault California, get your free consultation with one of our most qualified attorneys in California today!