Frequently Asked Questions About Criminal Defense
California’s criminal procedure can be extremely stressful and confusing to individuals charged with criminal offenses. Here we answer some criminal defense FAQs in California.
What is the criminal process in California?
California’s criminal procedure chronologically entails an arrest or citation, arraignment, preliminary examination, pre-trial, trial, and sentencing.
What’s the difference between an arrest and a citation?
Police will issue a citation instead of an arrest if they believe that the defendant is highly unlikely to not appear in court. However, if law enforcement believes otherwise, they will make an arrest.
California police may arrest an individual suspected of a crime:
- For a misdemeanor offense (if they have probable cause and witnessed the offense being committed, or have an arrest warrant)
- For a felony offense (if they have probable cause that the felony was committed, have witness testimony, or have an arrest warrant)
With a citation, the defendant will receive a “notice to appear in court” and not be apprehended.
What happens after a police arrest?
After the arrest, apprehended individuals can expect a police search (if warranted), interrogation, and to be taken into pre-trial custody.
During the interrogation, arrestees have the right to remain silent. Police must make this clear by reading the apprehended individual their Miranda rights. After the interrogation, defendants will be taken to a city or county jail, not state prison. While jail is a place to hold arrested defendants, prison is for individuals convicted of a crime.
Once the defendant is in jail, the police can choose to either release the defendant with a “notice to appear in court” or keep them in jail until the arraignment.
What happens at an arraignment?
An arraignment is a brief court hearing in which:
- The judge reads the charges filed against the defendant by the District Attorney
- The judge sets the bail amount
- The defendant is informed of their rights, including the right to a public defender
- The defendant is asked if they would like to plead, guilty, not guilty, or no contest
What’s the difference between pleading guilty, no guilty, and no contest?
In a guilty plea, the defendant admits to the accused crime and receives sentencing without trial. In a not guilty plea, the defendant denies committing the crime; the case then goes to trial where a California court must prove the defendant guilty. In a no-contest plea, the defendant does not admit or deny committing the crime; they allow the court to convict and sentence them without trial.
Guilty and no contest pleas result in the same punishment.
What happens after the arraignment?
After the arraignment, defendants have the right to a preliminary examination in which they and their attorney can claim that the police did not have probable cause to make the arrest. If proven, the charges are dropped and the defendant can walk free.
California’s pre-trial criminal procedure chronologically entails setting the trial date, discovery, and potential legal defense modifications.
During discovery, the District Attorney and Defense attorney exchange evidence pertinent to the trial. The District Attorney and Defense Attorney must exchange all documents that will be presented at trial 30 days before the trial date.
During pre-trial, defendants can make a “Marsden motion” requesting a new public defender, hire a criminal defense attorney, or make a “Faretta motion” choosing self-representation.
If you’re facing criminal charges, professional legal help is only a call away. Her Lawyer can connect you to the criminal defense lawyer of your choice. At your request, we’ll get you in touch with one of our female criminal defense attorneys.
Before the trial date, the District Attorney and Defense Attorney gather 12 impartial jurors for jury selection.
When will my trial date be set?
California guarantees the right to a Speedy Trial;
- Defendants charged with a felony can have their trial begin within 60 days of the arraignment
- Defendants in police custody charged with a misdemeanor can have their trial begin within 30 days of the arraignment
- Defendants not in police custody charged with a misdemeanor can have their trial begin within 45 days of the arraignment
What happens in a criminal trial in California?
In all criminal cases, defendants are innocent until proven guilty. In order for the defendant to be convicted, all 12 jurors must believe the defendant is “beyond a reasonable doubt”.
First, the District Attorney, then the Defense Attorney, give their opening statements, summarizing their perspectives, evidence, and respective arguments. After opening statements, the prosecutors, then the defense, call witnesses and present evidence that strengthens their case.
The defendant has the choice to testify (in self-defense) or not to testify (to avoid self-incrimination). The court must honor this choice no matter what.
After the prosecution and defense give their closing statements, the jury is sent to a private room to deliberate.
What happens when a verdict is reached in a criminal case?
Once a verdict is reached among the jury, the court clerk returns to the courtroom and announces the verdict. If found guilty, the judge orders the criminal sentence. A criminal sentence can include a fine, restitution, restraining order, imprisonment, or death,
What’s the difference between a felony and a misdemeanor in California?
A misdemeanor is less severe than a felony. Misdemeanors carry maximum sentences of one-year imprisonment and a $1,000 fine. A person convicted of a felony may go to prison or jail for at least one year and may receive a maximum fine of $10,000.
What’s the difference between a state crime and a federal crime?
A state crime violates state law, while a federal crime violates federal law.
What are the elements of a crime in California?
The three elements of a crime are:
- Attendant circumstances
Do the police need to read my rights when arresting me?
Police are required to read your Miranda rights if they arrest you AND interrogate you. If the police do not interrogate you, they are not required to read your rights.
Do police need to show an arrest warrant when making an arrest?
Yes, California police must present the signed arrest warrant to the apprehended person if requested “as soon as practicable”.
Is a search warrant the same as an arrest warrant?
A search warrant is not the same as an arrest warrant. A judge must sign a search warrant to search an apprehended person’s property or have probable cause to do so.
What is a bail hearing?
In a bail hearing, a judge decides whether to allow the defendant to post bail, which would allow them to be released from police custody before trial. The judge also sets the bail cost.
Do I need to talk to the police if I have been arrested?
No, arrested individuals do not need to answer police questioning. All defendants have the right to remain silent.
What is the difference between an acquittal and a not guilty verdict?
An acquittal means that the defendant is absolved of the charges against them, while a not guilty verdict means that the jury did not have enough evidence to prove the defendant guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. A not guilty verdict acquits a defendant from the charges against them.
What’s the difference between a criminal case and a civil case?
Crimes are offenses that violate criminal laws, while civil cases involve legal disputes between two individuals.
How long do criminal trials take in California?
Criminal jury trials last anywhere between a few days to a few months. The duration of a criminal case is dependent upon the circumstances at hand.
What do a prosecuting attorney and a defense attorney do in a criminal case?
While the prosecutor tries to prove that the defendant is guilty, the defense attorney tries to prove that the defendant is innocent.